« Canadian Bloggers Get Some Legitimacy | Main | Favorite Posts of 2009 (2) »

December 29, 2009

Comments

If I may ask your feelings on the first year of Obama's term?

To be fair I will state I feel betrayed to say the least.

I do believe at this point he is incapable of leading or holding this office. His steady diet of lies, backtracks or what ever word fits has shown me that his campaign was PR not truth. He did not believe what he was saying in his speeches which now are only empty words.

His actions during the Health Care bill (?) were beyond belief. I can't help thinking about his story of his mother. In the hospital near death fighting the insurance company for payment of her bills. And he, Obama, holds a secret meeting with the insurance companies and cuts a deal that will change nothing in that area. Who would do that to their mother's memory?

Was it the biggest story of the year, YES, and the most sorrowful for me and I know many more. So much hope was in the air, as you wrote in you piece, feelings that we came out of the darkness into an era of Peace and Justice, now neither seem possible.

I write this in the spirit of continuing a good discussion.

Hi Hal, thanks for writing this, I'm glad if this end-of-the-year post can spur some further discussion. In general I feel acutely disappointed, rather than betrayed, because I don't blame the man as much as the system. I think (as is usually the case, but sadly more true this time) Obama promised much more than he could deliver, and found himself as captain of a ship that can't be turned around, but merely nudged in a slightly better direction while fine words fly by like the wind. The health care debacle was predictable - I guess we should be glad something passed, but it's way way less than what's needed. I feel the same sharp disappointment on climate issues. My sense of betrayal is not over these points, though, but over Afghanistan: sending more troops is, to me, not a compromise but something unforgivable: a slap in the face to the people who put him in office, and an indication that this is a person willing to cave in on key issues. That bodes very badly for the future of this administration. I was also quite upset by him invoking "just war" in his Nobel Peace Prize speech. Basically, the policies we're seeing are what I would have expected from Hillary Clinton, not Obama: maintaining the status quo, not implementing real, visionary change. What's depressing is that real change may not be possible: this man had the best chance and the biggest mandate in a generation, and it's not working; the forces against it are too great. But I'm still glad he's in there, rather than his opponents, and hope he can accomplish some of what he set out to do.

I think actually Hillary would've been a better president, albeit slightly more hawkish. Like a lot of people, I supported Obama because I did believe he would be better on foreign relations, but at this point it's not clear if the diffenence is one of substance or style. (And conversely, who knows about Hilary -- how much of her hawkishness as a senator was just in preparation for the presidential race, knowing she couldn't appear weak.) Then again, I did not expect a radical break from Wilsonian imperialism, so like you I'd say I feel disappointed rather than betrayed. There are a number of areas where he has shown himself unwilling to spend polital capital for progressive goals.

Good choice of best posts, by the way. I think I would've made the very same selection so far.

Excellent choices, all, Beth, but March 20th jangled with me in particular.

Thanks, Dave. Curious to hear what you think of the final ten.

And thanks, Dick. I'm gratified you remembered or looked up these links, and that those thoughts on blogging resonated with you too.

I'm eager for the other six, Beth. Hoping maybe for the dentist sequence. One of the things I love about your blog is the way you piece together the different scraps/levels of concern/ that make public and private life. Because we all live in both and supporting the shifts in focus is one of the capacities you possess so richly. So the scraps become treasures and this is a gift to all of us who have more than a single pointed focus. Which is not the same as lacking singleness of heart, but it often feels like a betrayal of self ...Au contraire! .. I submit your year's oeuvre as proof!

Oh, Vivian, thanks. As the year winds down I'm reflecting, as usual, on where I've been last year and where I'm going next (a big question right now), and this question of single-pointedness vs. piecework is always the crux of it. It's good to hear that the way I am is somehow helpful.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

Who was Cassandra?


  • In the Iliad, she is described as the loveliest of the daughters of Priam (King of Troy), and gifted with prophecy. The god Apollo loved her, but she spurned him. As a punishment, he decreed that no one would ever believe her. So when she told her fellow Trojans that the Greeks were hiding inside the wooden horse...well, you know what happened.

MY SMALL PRESS