« Hermit Diary 25: Susan Rothenberg and the essence of things | Main | Hermit Diary 27: A Summer Already Ablaze »

May 29, 2020

Comments

I have worked hard with Purcell (Evening Hymn, Fairest Isle, I attempt from Love's Sickness, My Dearest, My fairest) but cheerily so, knowing there was light at the end of the tunnel. Blinding light, in fact.

I wondered, idly, if he was being short-changed in this comparison with Sumsion who plied his trade in Gloucester just down the road from where I live. To tell the truth, I'd have been surprised if this were the case and your judgment (only implied) was of course confirmed. Apart from being way below my lowest groans the bass line also majors on those jerky figures which I can't say I find entirely congenial unless in a much more diluted form, as in Fairest Isle. I also find it difficult to reconcile some of the critical comments associated with the YouTube clip: "technical humour", "amusing background", "great humorous ditty", "a sort of joke".

Sumsion's setting is of course choral and I agree that he uses repetition inventively. There's a seascape vigour throughout.

I append this comment as a form of penance. Like other Brits I tend to write off Britain's minor composers as being of no-account; due also to Shaw's rather caustic attitude, writing as Corno di Bassetto. This was sprited stuff.

The comments to this entry are closed.